From ‘Rorschach’ To ‘A Simple Favor’: A Guide To Must-Watch Mystery Thrillers On OTTplay Premium

The new mystery thriller Drop, which stars Meghann Fahy from The White Lotus, will be available on JioHotstar (accessed via OTTplay Premium) starting August 11, 2025. The movie, which also stars Brandon Sklenar, is about a widowed mother whose first date goes wrong when she gets an anonymous digital message telling her to follow a series of deadly instructions.

If the high-stakes, “date-gone-wrong” plot of Drop seems interesting to you, here is a selection of other great psychological and mystery thrillers on OTTplay Premium that you can add to your watchlist:

Rorschach: This Malayalam movie is a masterclass in how to mix psychological concepts with a story of revenge. After his wife goes missing, Luke Anthony moves to a small town in Kerala. Luke starts his own inquiry as the locals become more and more suspicious of him. This quest takes him into complicated family relationships and the harmful effects of greed. This is a really interesting movie to see because of Mammootty’s strong performance.

Inheritance: This movie is about a woman who finds out the grim truth about her father’s strange legacy and a man who has been held captive in a bunker. The story goes deep into how complicated family connections can be and how lies and secrets that have been kept for a long time may hurt people. The plot keeps you on the edge of your seat, making you wonder what the characters really want and why until the very end.

A Simple Favor is a beautiful and funny thriller that stars Anna Kendrick and Blake Lively. It tells the story of two very different women, Stephanie and Emily, who become friends in an unexpected way. When Emily goes missing without a trace, a gripping investigation reveals secret truths about her background and shows a darker side of Stephanie as well. The movie is a great tribute to classic Hitchcockian thrillers because of its dark humor and frightening storyline twists.

Jagged Mind: This psychological thriller tells the story of Billie, a lady who is stuck in a series of time loops and has blackouts and scary visions. She soon figures out that the problem is her unhealthy and controlling relationship with her new partner, Alex. Jagged Mind is a scary look into gaslighting, abuse, and the fight to get out of a bad cycle.

Gaslight: This Hindi-language psychological drama follows Meesha as she goes back to her family’s house after many years, only to find that her father is missing. She thinks her stepmother is making her doubt her own sanity. As Meesha learns about a web of horrible lies and betrayals, the movie also starts to disclose some dark truths about her own background, keeping the spectator wondering until the end.

Sookshmadarshini is a gripping Malayalam thriller about Priyadarshini, who starts to suspect her new neighbor, Manuel. Her own inquiry takes her down a dark path, revealing stunning secrets that build to a suspenseful and high-stakes finale. The film is a great example of how to generate suspense and tell a story that keeps people wondering at every turn.