Katy Perry Says "She Was Born On That Show" On Carrie Underwood Taking Over As 'American Idol' Judge

January 31, 2025: Katy Perry has shared her thoughts on country music superstar Carrie Underwood stepping into the judging role on American Idol, replacing Perry for the upcoming season.

Perry, who announced earlier that Season 22 would be her last on the show, praised Underwood’s deep connection to the competition, saying, “She was born on that show,” and that Underwood “knows how to steer it.” This comes six months after Underwood was revealed as part of the Idol judging panel, which also includes Lionel Richie and Luke Bryan.

Perry expressed confidence in Underwood's ability to bring valuable insight, noting that Underwood’s experience as a past contestant—having won Season 4 of American Idol—will allow her to understand the contestants' struggles in a way that Perry and her fellow judges could only metaphorically. "She actually truly knows ... what it feels like to be in the contestants' shoes," Perry explained. The Firework singer added that while the judges can empathize with the contestants, Underwood’s perspective would be unique and helpful.

Underwood is the most successful winner of American Idol, having won eight Grammy Awards and 25 accolades from the Academy of Country Music and Country Music Association. She has also topped the U.S. country charts with multiple albums, and her career continues to thrive. As for her return to Idol, Underwood is poised to bring a blend of honesty and constructive feedback, explaining that she plans to be “very honest, but hopefully, you know, very constructive and encouraging” with her judging.

After announcing her departure, Perry explained that she wanted to focus on her music and see the world. Underwood’s return to Idol marks an exciting chapter for the show, with the country star taking her seat on the panel for the 25th season.

As American Idol prepares for its 23rd season in early 2025, the new judging lineup, including Underwood, will certainly add an intriguing dynamic to the beloved competition show.