The latest DC outing, Supergirl, directed by Craig Gillespie, arrives in theatres with ambitious intent but uneven execution. Starring Milly Alcock, Eve Ridley, Jason Momoa, Matthias Schoenaerts, Emily Beecham, David Krumholtz, and David Corenswet, the film attempts to redefine Superman’s iconic cousin through a more emotionally grounded, character-driven narrative.
At its core, Supergirl follows Kara Zor-El as she embarks on a reluctant intergalactic journey alongside a young girl, Ruthye, in pursuit of the ruthless pirate Krem, who is responsible for devastating personal loss. The story blends elements of a revenge western, space opera, and coming-of-age drama, aiming to carve out a distinct identity for Kara beyond her famous Kryptonian legacy.
The film is at its strongest when it focuses on grief, identity, and emotional displacement rather than large-scale spectacle. The evolving bond between Kara and Ruthye becomes the narrative’s emotional anchor, offering moments of sincerity and depth whenever the screenplay allows it to breathe. However, frequent shifts toward expansive world-building, creature encounters, and action-heavy sequences often dilute the emotional impact, leaving the storytelling uneven.
Milly Alcock delivers a standout performance as Kara Zor-El, portraying the character with a raw, unpolished energy that captures both vulnerability and defiance. Eve Ridley also impresses as Ruthye, bringing emotional clarity and determination to a role that could easily have been overshadowed. Jason Momoa’s appearance as Lobo injects bursts of chaotic charisma, briefly lifting the film whenever he appears on screen, while Matthias Schoenaerts’ antagonist Krem remains serviceable but underwritten.
Visually, the film constructs a vast cosmic landscape filled with unusual worlds and eccentric characters, though the imagery often prioritizes scale over memorability. Action sequences are competently staged but rarely linger in the memory. Claudia Sarne’s electronic score provides consistent momentum, enhancing scenes that might otherwise feel narratively thin.
Despite its inconsistencies, Supergirl shows flashes of promise, especially when it leans into its more intimate emotional storytelling rather than blockbuster spectacle. The film ultimately struggles to maintain a steady tone but manages to suggest stronger possibilities for future instalments in the franchise.